Tips for Baking Muffins

These tips for baking muffins will help you make your muffins the best they can be!

muffin pans, liners, scoops, and other tools for baking muffins

Muffins are a great for a sweet breakfast treat or just a snack. They’ve always been a favorite baking project for me. Whether you like the uncomplicated classics or more elaborate muffins, there are some simple things to keep in mind when baking muffins. These are my tips for baking muffins so that they’re the best they can be!

Before I get into the specifics, don’t forget some general baking recommendations. Measure ingredients accurately. Check the accuracy of your oven’s temperature. Use quality ingredients. Don’t use dark or shiny pans. Any substitutions you make will affect the final outcome.

You can find plenty of muffin recipes in my Recipe Index, and I’ve also interspersed some favorites among these tips for a little baking inspiration.

Chocolate Chip Muffins served on a white plate

Chocolate Chip Muffins

Mixing Muffin Batter

It is very possible to overmix muffin batter. In fact, I’d guess that it happens more often than not in most cases. Most muffins are mixed using the muffin method, which incorporates all the wet ingredients into the dry ingredients all at once. This method is used to create the desired texture of muffins, but it also helps you get your batter made with minimal mixing to avoid toughness.

You should stir the batter just until the dry ingredients are moistened. In most cases, that is likely 10 to 12 turns with a mixing spoon. You shouldn’t need to get out your electric mixer for traditional muffins. Unlike other mixtures, you aren’t likely to end up with a smooth batter. A few lumps and streaks of flour are just fine. You can read more details in The Muffin Method.

basket of Brown Butter Strawberry Muffins

Brown Butter Strawberry Muffins

Filling Muffin Cups

As a general rule, fill your muffin cups about 3/4 full. That should leave enough room for the muffins to rise without making a mess. Of course, if the specific recipe you’re using directs otherwise, then go with that. The different recommendations are due to the fact that there may be some variance depending on how much the muffins in a specific recipe will rise as they bake.

Most muffins are baked at high temperatures to help make them nice and tall. That’s not vital for success, but it’s worth making a mental note that the temperature has an influence in that department. It’s common to see muffin recipes require 375° or 400°F. That allows them to rise more quickly to give them height.

Pecan Spice Muffins cooling on a wire rack

Pecan Spice Muffins

Making Muffin Batter in Advance

I’m occasionally asked if muffin batter can be made in advance to bake later, and the short answer is no. The why of that is all about leavening. When you use baking soda and/or baking powder, they become activated when they become wet. Letting the batter sit before baking will almost certainly cause your muffins not to rise as they should.

The longer answer is that you could mix the dry and wet ingredients separately and then combine them just before you’re ready to bake. That might save you a few minutes of prep time for a busy morning. However, you’ll want everything fairly close to room temperature, which means you might need to let the wet ingredients sit at room temperature for a bit before adding them to the dry ingredients.

As a general rule, it’s just not a great idea to try to make muffin batter in advance. The good news is that muffins usually will keep for a few days, so you can bake them in advance. Simply reheat them if you want a warm muffin. A few minutes at a low oven temp or even a few seconds in the microwave will usually do the trick.

Jam-Filled Doughnut Muffins

Jam-Filled Doughnut Muffins

Lining Muffin Cups

Whether or not you line muffin cups before baking muffins is really a matter of preference. The main difference it makes baking-wise is how it affects the texture of the muffins, specifically the outsides of them. With a liner, the outsides will be softer. But without liners, you’ll get a crisper, browner outside because of the lack of that layer between the batter and the pan.

Another consideration I take into account is how the muffins will be served. If you’re baking muffins for your family to enjoy or to serve all at once, then lined or unlined is just fine. If you need to travel with the muffins or intend for them to be a grab-and-go treat, then liners make sense.

Portioning Muffin Batter

My preferred method for portioning muffin batter is with a scoop. Many standard size muffins need about 3 tablespoons of batter per cup, so a 3-tablespoon scoop is the perfect tool for portioning and transferring the batter. All your muffins will be the same size, which is not only nicer looking but also important for making sure the muffins all bake evenly. It’s also a quicker and less messy method. Once you try it, I think you’ll be sold on doing it that way!

Cranberry Orange Muffins in a red dish

Cranberry Orange Muffins

Choosing Muffin Pans

As with most of my other baking pan recommendations, I prefer a light colored, non-shiny pan. Those types of pans tend to give the best results. With standard, mini, jumbo, and more pan sizes, just be sure you’re using the right size for the recipe. You can find some recommended pans and other tools in my Muffin Baking Essentials list on my Amazon Storefront.

Keeping Add-Ins from Sinking

The thing to consider here is gravity. If you add things to your batter that are too heavy, they will sink. There’s nothing that can really be done about that. There are a few things you can do to combat this, like using smaller pieces. You can read much more about this in How to Keep Chocolate Chips from Sinking.

Pineapple Coconut Banana Nut Muffins on a white plate with yellow trim

Pineapple Coconut Banana Nut Muffins

Testing Muffins for Doneness

The recipe should instruct you how to tell if the muffins are done baking. Usually, that includes the common pick test. When you stick a pick into the center of a muffin, it should come out clean or with just a few moist crumbs. From there, you’ll likely be instructed to cool the muffins in the pans for a short time before transferring them to a wire rack to finish cooling. Don’t leave them in the pan too long, or you’ll end up with soggy muffins.

Preventing Holes or Tunnels in Muffins

This is all about mixing, which was the first thing I covered in these tips. Too much, and your leavening agents (like baking powder and baking soda) can’t quite do their job right, and that leads to muffins with large holes or tunnels in them. There’s not necessarily anything wrong with that, but overmixing is also what leads to tough muffins, so you may have more than one issue on your hands.

Quick and Easy Blueberry Muffins

Quick and Easy Blueberry Muffins

I hope I’ve helped with everything you’ve ever wanted to know about baking muffins. If you’re in a muffin baking mood now, you can find plenty of muffin recipes in my Recipe Index. And if you have any other questions, please let me know in the comments below.

If you’d like my recommendations for pans and tools for baking muffins, be sure to visit my Muffin Baking Essentials list on my Amazon Storefront.

Happy baking!

Bake or Break is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Share this: