Are your cookies less than perfect? Let’s fix them with these baking tips for preventing common cookie problems!

tips for preventing common cookie problems

We all love freshly baked homemade cookies, but sometimes things don’t quite go as we envisioned them. There are a lot of little things that can go wrong to make your cookies less than perfect.

I’ve baked countless batches of cookies over the years, and I’ve encountered my fair share of subpar cookies. I’m here to help fix your cookie baking problems with some cookie baking tips for how to prevent the most common issues.

In my experience of baking and discussing baking with many of you, these are the most common issues I’ve seen. Keep in mind that if you choose to alter a recipe in any way, you may create other issues with your cookies. For instance, if you use a different type of flour or substitute for a major ingredient like butter, you’re likely to have very different results. If you have any other issues not covered here, feel free to ask in the comments.

And because we’re all here for the cookies (right???), I’ve included some of BoB’s most popular cookie recipes for a little baking inspiration.

Coconut-Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies

Coconut-Salted Caramel Thumbprint Cookies

Why are my cookies unevenly browned?

If some of your cookies seem more brown than others, the dough may not have been portioned equally. Using the same amount of dough for each cookie means that they will bake in the same amount of time. If some are too small, they’ll get too brown. If some are too big, then they’ll not get brown enough.

For drop cookies (like chocolate chip and oatmeal), the best way to portion dough is to use a cookie scoop. Cookie scoops are spring-release scoops that are available in various sizes. I never bake drop cookies without a scoop. I’ve talked much more about them in A Baker’s Guide to Cookie Scoops, which includes a handy chart for choosing the right size scoop.

For slice and bake cookies, use a ruler or other guide to make sure the cookies are sliced to the same thickness. That may seem a bit fussy, but that extra step will reward you with beautiful, evenly baked cookies.

For cut-out cookies, make sure that the dough is rolled out to an even thickness. Again, a ruler is handy for this. There are also rolling pins with removable guides to gauge thickness as you roll the dough.

It’s also possible that there’s a hot or cold spot in your oven. You can test this by making a single layer of sliced bread on a sheet pan and baking at 350°F for a few minutes until the bread begins to toast. It will then be easy to tell if you have a hot or cold spot by any variance in the browning of the bread. (This also works with coconut, and you’ll have some toasted coconut for a baking project when you’re done!)

To try to counteract any hot or cold spots, you may need to rotate your pan about halfway through baking cookies for more even browning.

stack of Cream Cheese Peanut Butter Cookies

Cream Cheese Peanut Butter Cookies

Why are my cookies tough?

The most common reason that cookies are tough is that the cookie dough was mixed too much. When flour is mixed into the dough, gluten begins to form. Gluten helps hold baked goods together, but too much gluten can lead to tough cookies.

When mixing the flour into the cookie dough, only mix the dough until no streaks of flour are visible. If adding nuts, chocolate chips, or another ingredient after the flour, you can even stop mixing the flour into the dough when there are a few streaks of flour visible in the dough. Then, add the other ingredients, and the flour will finish mixing into the dough as the other ingredients are stirred into the dough.

You can also let the dough rest before baking to let the gluten relax a bit. Many cookie recipes will direct you to chill the dough before baking for this reason and also for cutting down on how much your cookies spread.

Browned Butter Salty Sugar Cookies

Browned Butter Salty Sugar Cookies

Why do my cookies spread too much?

Many of the reasons that cookies spread too much are related to the temperature of the ingredients or the dough. The most likely problem is that the butter was too soft when it was beaten. Remember that butter starts to soften at about 65°F, so that’s significantly below room temperature for most of us.

It’s also possible that the dough may have become too warm before it was baked. In that case, simply place it in the refrigerator for about half an hour before baking.

Spreading can also be due to excessive greasing of the baking pans or placing cookie dough on warm pans. If it is necessary to reuse a baking pan while baking a batch of cookies, allow the pan to cool to room temperature before placing more dough on the pan.

For more about cookie spreading, see my post How to Keep Cookies from Spreading.

Butter Pecan Oatmeal Cookies

Butter Pecan Oatmeal Cookies

Why do my cookies stick to the pan?

Not greasing or lining baking pans can cause cookies to stick to the pans. Cookies can also stick if they are removed from the pans before they have cooled properly.

To prevent sticking, line the pans with parchment paper or silicone liners, or lightly grease the pan with butter or cooking spray. Keep in mind that excessive greasing can cause cookies to spread too much. You can read more about this in Unlined vs Lined Baking Sheets, but do know that I highly recommend lining pans versus greasing them.

Be sure to place the pans of baked cookies on a wire rack to cool for a few minutes before removing them from the pan. This allows air to circulate around the pan to cool them more quickly and prevent too much carryover baking from the heat of the pan.

Oatmeal Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Oatmeal Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

Why are my cookies dry?

The most common reason cookies are dry is too much flour. Over-measuring flour is a very common reason for most any recipe to fail. If you scoop your measuring cup down into the flour container to measure, then odds are you’re using too much.

The best way to measure flour is by weight or the spoon and sweep method. It can make such a big difference. For my tips on how to measure flour properly, be sure to see How to Measure Flour.

Key Lime Crinkle Cookies

Key Lime Crinkle Cookies

Why are the bottoms of my cookies too brown?

If the cookies are baked perfectly except that the bottoms are overly brown, the most likely problem is the baking pan. A dark pan absorbs more heat and will bake the bottoms of the cookies faster. Use a metal pan with a dull finish for best results.

Also, be mindful of where your oven rack is during baking. As a general rule, you want to bake cookies in the top third of your oven. Some recipes may specify differently, but otherwise I assume that the top third is the best choice.

Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookies

Favorite Chocolate Chip Cookies

Why are my cookies overbaked?

If your cookies are consistently overbaked, that is very simply either due to temperature or time.

It’s not uncommon for your oven’s temperature reading to be inaccurate. An oven thermometer is an inexpensive tool that is invaluable to bakers. Place it inside the oven and compare its reading to your oven’s temperature setting to determine if the oven’s temperature is accurate. Then, adjust the temperature setting as needed to accommodate for any inaccuracy.

As for the time aspect, remember the saying that if something is done in the oven, it will be overdone out of the oven. Removing cookies from the oven doesn’t magically stop baking them. The residual heat will continue to bake them for a few minutes.

Follow the recipe’s guidelines for when to remove the cookies from the oven. Most recipes will direct you to remove the cookies when they are lightly browned. After that, don’t let them linger too long on the pans. Unless otherwise specified in the recipe, remove the cookies from the pan after about 5 minutes and transfer them to a wire rack to allow them to finish cooling.

Chocolate Blackout Cookies

Chocolate Blackout Cookies

I hope these cookie baking tips help you solve your cookie problems. Most often, a small adjustment is all you need to bake perfect batches of cookies.

May your worst cookie problem be that you’re out of cookies! Happy baking!

Bake or Break is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.

Share this:

sign up for free email updates:

    39 Comments on “Common Cookie Problems and How to Prevent Them”

  1. I just wanted to thank you for your timely “Common cookie problem” guide!! At the holidays even the experienced baker who doesn’t bake that often throughout the year has issues when it comes time for holiday baking. Thanks again Jennifer for this valuable information and wishing all a safe and happy holiday season.

    • My pleasure, Meg! I hope you find it helpful. Happy holidays to you, too.

      • Hi Jennifer, thanks for the helpful info, anyway I have on and on problem, I swap the flour to rolled out and tapioca flour, swap sugar to honey, and swap butter to margarine. Then my cookies come out in greasy, sticky, not crispy and not sturdy. Any advice for me to get a crispy outside, chewy inside, sturdy, and not greasy? Thank you

        • Hi! That’s a lot of changes, so I would expect things not to turn out like the original recipe. If you want to make those kinds of substitutions, you may need to do a little experimenting to figure out how to make it work for you.

  2. Love your recipes! I have a question – after dropping cookie dough onto a sheet using a cookie scoop should the cookies be flattened with the bottom of a glass? 

    • Thanks, Eileen! Flattening the cookie dough is usually done to help shape the end result, so it’s sometimes helpful and sometimes not. It depends on how much the cookies will spread on their own. For my recipes, I will include that step in the directions if I find that it’s necessary.

  3. I would like to print some of your recipes but can’t.  Will you share and tell me how?
    Thank you

  4. Why don’t my cookies don’t spread when I put the dough in pan it just set there then they get hard

    • If you’re not changing anything about a recipe, then you may have too much flour. If you scoop down into the flour container to measure, odds are you are using too much. See my tips for How to Measure Flour.

    • Hi! This is a super helpful article – thank you for sharing for those of us trying to perfect our cookies 🙂

      One issue I keep running into is uneven baking and weird shapes… despite following the recipe to a T, chilling the dough, rotating the cookie sheet half way through, using a light/dull cookie sheet (William Sonoma brand) and of course using parchment paper underneath. Any thoughts?

      Full disclosure I do sometimes try to make cookies with Oreos or something inside. What would you suggest for helping make a “normal” cookie shape that doesn’t look like the top half of Saturn?? Haha. And even weirder, it’s only some of the cookies that come out this way. Would love any help!!

      • Hi, Virginia. Uneven baking could be a hot or cold spot in your oven. Consistent shaping is key to having consistent sizing in the final result. Putting something inside the cookies will definitely affect the shape. That Oreo inside isn’t going to change much during baking, but all the dough around it certainly will. The cookie is still going to rise and spread, even if that’s on top of or around something inside.

  5. Hi, can you tell me why my dough does not roll . Dough is breaking apart. Help me please.

  6. Jennifer I enjoy your articles and recipes. I love cooking and baking and so many sites have turned into what look like “advertisements” for various companies. I understand ” affiliations” and links and I appreciate the importance as well as the helpfulness. Your presentation is without the “advertising” affect; yet with the helpful links if wanted. Your explanations on recipes are thorough and concise as well. I also love recipes that take one printed page. A long speech to say you do a great job in my opinion and thanks for sharing your knowledge and great foods.

  7. I am going through fits trying to make gluten free cookies that won’t be brittle or dry and the additional problem is that I am having to also substitute sugar anyway I can, so I don’t have a diabetic issue happening in our household.  The problem is that the cookies end up being so dry they are overly brittle and break into sand like pieces.  I don’t mind using apple sauce in place of sugar, if I can, but artificial sweeteners don’t seem to work right in making cookies.  HELP, Please??????

    • Hi, Mary. I’m a traditional baker, so I don’t have much experience with substitutes for flour and sugar. Remember that sugar adds moisture, so it may just be as simple as lacking enough moisture by removing the sugar. Try adding more liquid to the recipe, either by increasing existing liquid in the recipe or maybe just adding some water.

  8. I am planning to use Pamela’sglutin free pancake and baking mix for my cookies.  What is your opinion for this substitute flour?

    • Hi, Liz. I’ve not tried that product, so I can’t offer any advice. That it’s called a pancake and baking mix sounds like it’s more like Bisquick than plain flour, but again I haven’t seen it or used it. If you try it, let me know how it works.

  9. My sand tart cookie dough is sticky and won’t roll in a ball. Any idea why. 

  10. Hi,

    I am very new to baking and facing issue with browning of cookie. The cookie surface is getting evenly browned but on the bottom only the sides are getting browned, the middle portion looks raw and is little cakey. I have tried
    1) Changing the baking sheet
    2) Reducing the temperature to 170 degree from usual 180 degree
    If the bottom bakes up evenly I think the cookie come s out beautifully. Please help on what I may be doing wrong and how to fix. Thanks

    • Hello! If your cookies are getting done more quickly on the outside than the inside, then my best guesses would be that your oven temperature is too high (or inaccurate, which you can test with an oven thermometer) or that you’re using a dark pan. A light-colored, non-shiny pan tends to work best. Also, make sure your rack is in the center of the oven.

  11. Hii..I baked the cookies at 175 degrees for 13 minutes but they are not brown and easily broken . Please advise me what to do

  12. Why my butter turns out runny when I used hand whisk to mix the white sugar and light brown sugar?

    • It sounds like your butter is getting too warm. Butter begins to melt at around 68°F, so it doesn’t need to come to room temperature. Mixing warms it some, too, so keep that in mind as well.

  13. I like soft and chewy cookies. So do my neighbors who I like to treat with my baking. How can I make sure that they stay that way. I usually take the cookies out of the oven just before they look done. I have also tried adding corn syrup to the batter.

    What do you suggest to make every cookie recipe soft and chewy?

    • Not every cookie is designed to be soft and chewy. I usually try to describe the texture of the cookie recipes I share, so pay attention to how they’re described here or wherever you’re looking at recipes. For cookies that should be soft and chewy, make sure you’re measuring your ingredients (especially flour) accruately, don’t over-mix, and don’t over-bake.

  14. Hi mam , i want to know when we remove baked cookies from tray it stick to our fingers. How to prevent cookies from it. Plz tell

  15. Hi Jennifer, My biscuits are always getting soggy once dipped in milk or tea. What should be done to prevent biscuits from being soggy but still crunchy?

    • The texture of the cookie has a lot to do with that. Crispier, drier cookies will hold up the best for dunking. If the cookie is already soft, it’s likely not to work well. Look for recipes that specify the cookies are crispy and crunchy.

  16. Hi I just wanna ask I’m new in baking what should I do to avoid may cookies to break easily… Thanks alot

  17. Hey! So, I’ve tried baking cookies last time and they turned out to be cake-like… How can I prevent this? I used oil instead of butter since I had none at the time, is that the reason? Haha.. Im doing it myself without my mom’s assistance so maybe I did something incorrectly..?

    • Hello! My first guess would be that you’re using too much flour. That’s pretty common and easy to do. See my tips for How to Measure Flour. Also, oil and butter aren’t always a 1:1 substitution. In many cases, you’d need to use about 3/4 as much oil as the butter in a recipe. Also, if you’re supposed to cream the butter in the recipe, then oil is generally not a good substitution.

Leave a Reply to Pia Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *