Butter Pecan Cake
It’s been a while since I had a non-chocolate recipe on BoB. Personally, I don’t think there’s any such thing as too much chocolate, but maybe variety isn’t such a bad thing, either.
Granted, this cake does have a bit of white chocolate in it, but I don’t count that. White chocolate is an entirely different entity in my book. In fact, I’m not normally a big fan of the stuff. It’s usually far too sweet for my liking. (Did I really just type that?!?) If any recipe can make me change my mind, it’s this one.
I found this recipe while flipping through Christmas With Southern Living 2005. I have no idea how I skipped over it back then. Having made and tasted this cake, I am so sad for my past self that it took me four years to get around to making it.
You can tell by the photos that this three-layer cake looks suspiciously like a two-layer cake. Honestly, that’s what happens when one layer doesn’t quite turn out the way you want. That turned out to be a good thing. Quinn, the official froster of the BoB kitchen, thinks that making the frosting cover an extra layer would have been a challenge.
I must say that this cake is fabulous. It is definitely near the top of my list of favorite cakes. The white chocolate is not overpowering. The cake is just right. And that frosting! I could be happy with a shot of that for dessert any time.
This cake is just as delicious as it is beautiful. It’s a great dessert for a special occasion or to make an everyday occasion special.
Butter Pecan Cake
Yield: 12 to 14 servings
Prep Time:30 minutes
Cook Time:32 minutes
Plenty of nuts and white chocolate make this Butter Pecan Cake a delicious, irresistible dessert.
Ingredients:
For the frosting:
- 2 tablespoons unsalted butter
- 1 & 1/4 cups coarsely chopped pecans
- 11 ounces cream cheese, softened
- 1/2 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 16 ounces confectioners’ sugar
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
For the cake:
- 6 ounces white chocolate, chopped
- 1/2 cup boiling water
- 1 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 1 & 1/2 cups granulated sugar
- 4 large eggs, separated
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup buttermilk
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 3 cups sifted cake flour
- toasted pecan halves for garnishing, if desired
Directions:
To make the frosting:
- Melt 2 tablespoons butter in a large skillet. Add the pecans and cook over medium heat, stirring occasionally, until toasted – about 10 minutes. Remove from heat and cool completely.
- Using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat the cream cheese and 1/2 cup butter until creamy. Gradually add the sugar. Beat until light and fluffy. Stir in the buttered pecans and vanilla. Cover and chill at least 1 hour.
To make the cake:
- Place the white chocolate in a bowl and pour boiling water over it, stirring until smooth. Set aside to cool.
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease three 9-inch round cake pans and line with wax paper. Grease and flour the wax paper.
- Using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat the butter until creamy. Gradually add the sugar, beating well. Add the egg yolks, one at a time, beating after each addition. Stir in the melted white chocolate and vanilla.
- Combine the buttermilk and baking soda. Add the flour to the butter mixture, alternating with the buttermilk mixture. Begin and end with the flour. Mix at low speed after each addition until blended.
- Beat the egg whites to stiff peaks. Gently fold into batter. Pour the batter evenly into the prepared pans.
- Bake for 20-22 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted in the center of cake comes out clean. Cool in the pans for 10 minutes. Then, remove from pans to wire racks to cool completely.
- Spread the frosting between layers and on the top and sides of cake. Garnish, if desired. Store in refrigerator.
Notes:
This is indeed a 3-layer cake, despite the fact that I only used 2 layers. That just made for a higher frosting to cake ratio!
Recipe slightly adapted from Christmas with Southern Living 2005.
This post contains affiliate links.
108 Comments on “Butter Pecan Cake”
wow, this looks great. I love butter pecan, and the white chocolate sounds like an interesting twist.
O-M-G!! You have the greatest desserts. I wish I could try every single one of them.
Yum. How did you know that butter pecan is one of my favorite flavors?
I need taste-o-vision on my computer. And/or a napkin to wipe the drool! =)
Love the texture.
This looks beautiful. I love just about everything in it. Totally bookmarked and hopefully going to be made within the next four years 😉
😂😂😂
Wowza! That cake looks crazy good. I love Southern Living, and the cake definitely looks like a SL cake. It’s gorgeous, and it looks sinfully rich.
Mmm, that looks delcious! I want!
Desde hace un mes no tenía receta nueva tuya. Esta tiene un pinta estupenda. Gracias
This sounds delicious and the perfect break from chocolate. I can’t wait to try it.
Oh yum delicious. I love a variant from chocolate in cakes, and this seems just the perfect thing. It’s gorgeous looking too!
Pingback: Tweets that mention Butter Pecan Cake | Bake or Break -- Topsy.com
Sounds seriously delicious….
It’s beautiful and perfectly wintery looking. Glad to see you back! I always love your recipes.
The cake looks super moist and soft. Share please!
Thank you so much for posting this recipe! I made it this weekend for my in-laws. They loved it! Thanks for making me look like a baking superstar!
I really hear you that one can never have too much chocolate. But if you’re not going to have chocolate, you might as well have butter pecan…this cake looks completely magnificent and flavourful. One to bookmark for sure.
This cake looks to DIE FOR! It is so nice to see a post from you again! I have to admit… I missed them (: You’re my fav food blog (shh don’t tell!)
Looks so yummy I can hardly stand it!! Can’t wait to try!!!
I’m look at as many food blogs as I can looking for a good dessert for chef test I have on Friday. There’s some great ideas in here!
This looks insanely delicious. I’m yet to venture into two-layer cakes, let alone three, but think this is the one to break me in!
Looks amazing, nice woork!!!!
I tried this recipe on the weekend, but made a last minute decision to do cupcakes instead (Superbowl party so they were easier to eat). While the end result was delicious, I unfortunately thought I could get away without using cupcake wrappers – not a good idea. The cake itself is super delicate and fluffy which made it very difficult to remove from the cupcake pan. I’d definitely make it again, except either as a cake (in a well lined pan) or with cupcake wrappers.
THANK YOU!
For once someone has left a review after actually having made the recipe. Don’t know abt you, but personally I don’t care if it looks amazing, I want to know if it tastes good, was easy to make, etc
And your review is very helpful bc my daughter loves butter pecan and I’ve been going to make it, but you just never know. Especially the part abt making cupcakes, that’s usually what I always do and yes, there are times I don’t have any liners.
Again, thank you, thank you, thank you
I made this cake over the weekend for my grandmother’s birthday, and she absolutely LOVED it! More than one person at the party told me it was the best cake they had ever eaten! As an extreme chocoholic, I was a bit sad that she requested a cake that wasn’t chocolate, but I didn’t miss it one bit! The icing was wonderfully delicious, the cake was fluffy but moist. Just perfect! I will definitely be making this one again soon. Thanks so much for all the time and energy you put into making your blog so wonderful. It always brightens my day to see that you have a new post!
Oooo, this sounds right up my alley1 We’re not fans of chocolate but don’t mind some white. Thanks for passig this beauty along!
~ingrid
Made this cake tonight and it was wonderful! Everyone loved it. My brother even took a big chunk home and he’s not a big sweet eater. Will definitely be making again!
Pingback: Baking a Cake
It looks great and sounds delicious… so it must be!
OMG! I made this cake last weekend and it was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!! We are now addicts!
Amazing, what I wouldn’t give for a little tub of that frosting with me at work right now…just a little taste every few minutes to get me through this Friday!
wowwww!! this looks to die forrrr!! I wanna eat my laptop right now! but I don’t see where the recipe is.. please can you share it with ussss? 😀
calabaza_azul, the recipe link is above the top picture. Enjoy!
Love this recipe.
Wow, this looks amazing! I can’t believe I’ve never seen this recipe before.
Thanks for posting.
Kira
http://www.saturday-chef.blogspot.com
this looks amazing – just like everything else on your site
i see now, with toasted pecans – sorry for not reading more carefully
i made this cake – excellent, nice change from chocolate cakes. the white chocolate flavor really comes thru in the cake. thanks for posting the recipe
ive never heard of butter pecan cake it looks good
I made this cake with 3 layers and it turned out fantastic. Very sweet and rich but good and so pretty.
What a perfect dessert for celebrating National Pecan Month, which just happens to be in April!
Thank you so much for sharing…you have a delicious looking blog:)
The BEST cake I have ever made! Thanks for the recipe.
Pingback: Butter Pecan Cake Recipe – Best Friends For Frosting
there are so many cake recipes that we can choose from. my favorite are always those recipes that have chocolate in it. .”;”`Warmest regards
Pingback: Weekly Mix | Bake or Break
Pingback: Not Quite as Awesome as Hoped » My Writing Life
Should this recipe have any salt in it? I just noticed that it doesn’t seem to have any.
Thanks!
Sarah, the recipe is correct – no salt.
I made this cake today for my moms bday…the frosting was to die for but the cake came out firm more like pound cake with no fluff. Was it suppose to turn out that way? I followed the recipe exactly. Not sure what went wrong
Tiffany, it’s a fairly sturdy cake. If yours was just dense, it’s fine. If it was tough, then the batter may have been overmixed.
Made this for my husband’s birthday today. One word: perfect. Thank you for sharing this!
Hello! I’m really excited about making this cake. I do have a question. Are you supposed to pour the entire half cup of water over the chocolate or only enough so that it melts? Thanks!
Windea, you’ll need to use all of the water.
Pingback: Bake or Break | Weekly Mix: White Chocolate
If i were to make this in just one 9 inch pan could i then cut it in half etc? Would i need to adjust the baking time/temp for that if im trying to bake a larger volume? or should I just buy another cake tin XD
Hi, Orla. You can half the recipe. You’ll just need to use a pan that will accommodate half of the volume. A 9-inch round won’t be big enough, as this cake actually makes 3 layers. The closest common size pan that would work for half the volume is a 9-inch square. It will be a bit on the tall side, so just make sure it isn’t an unusually shallow pan. It may take a few extra minutes to bake due to its height.
may I use this recipe for a vanilla layered cake?…is it fluffy light?
Hi, Cheryl. I remember this being a nice texture, but I don’t know that I’d describe it as especially light. I’m sure it would work fine. I like a little bit of heft to it so it holds up well with plenty of frosting.
Pingback: Butter Pecan | Dessert
Pingback: Butter Pecan Cake | Dessert
Okay people. I caved. Printed off the recipe, went out, bought 35$ worth of ingredients and got to work on this extravaganza tonight. First off: 30 minutes prep time?? My ass! Let’s call it 2 1/2 hours from turning on the oven to putting these delicious pan-fillings into the heat. Next, 20-22 minutes bake time is completely off. 35 minutes did it for these cakes. But now we are in the wait for the frosting to tighten up stage and i could eat that up with a spoon. Also I over shot it on vanilla. Keep to the recipe measurements. Here’s to yummy results tomorrow for brunch.
Pingback: Top 15 Layer Cakes
Pingback: BoB’s Best Easter Desserts | Bake or Break
Pingback: Butter Pecan Cake | Food WoW
Pingback: The Sunday Favourites #12 | The Questionable Homesteader
If I wanted to make this recipe into cupcake would I bake same amount of time and how many would it make
Anna, you should get somewhere around 24 cupcakes. I’d bake them about 15 minutes before checking if they’re done. Then, add time if needed.
If I want to make this to fit in a 10″x4″ cake pan is it safe to double the recipe or would I need more batter?
Hi, Akilah. This is a 3-layer cake, which is a lot of batter. Do you mean 10″x4″ or did you mistype? If you meant 10″x14″, you won’t need to alter the recipe. The cake will be a bit taller, so just make sure your pan is not shallow. You may need to bake it a few more minutes to account for the added thickness.
I meant 10″round x 4″ high.
I certainly wouldn’t make the layers that tall. Doubling will give you way too much batter. You can still make the cake as directed and just have thinner layers. Or, just make two layers that are slightly thicker than you’d get from a 9-inch round.
Pingback: Best Easter Desserts - Bake or Break
I’ve made this cake from the original site…but I use chocolate ganache between the layers- solves the not quite enough pecan frosting and adds a bit of chocolate(okay more than a bit!) win-win!
I am looking forward to baking this cake, it sounds deelish!!!
Will salted butter work just as well in the cake and frosting?
Hi, Yvonne. The only difference will be (obviously) the salt. I am a big believer in using unsalted butter for baking so you can control the saltiness. Usually if someone wants to use salted butter, I suggest reducing the salt in the recipe. But there is no salt in this recipe, so you wouldn’t be able to make that alteration. The salt will really just affect the taste, not the consistency. Ultimately, if you don’t mind a salty cake and frosting, then it will be fine.
Can I sub the white chocolate for something else?
Hi, Vetta. If you don’t want to use white chocolate, I’d recommend just using your favorite cake recipe for a yellow or white cake. The frosting will work just fine with either of those. The cake recipe from this Pecan Cake could be used with or without the pecans.
I just replied to the first review I saw where someone had actually made the recipe to thank them for that instead of just saying how amazing it looks and they might try it. Then as I scrolled down and see where quite a few of you have made it and all the reviews are consistent. So I’m off to make it thanks to all you Trail Blazers
What did I miss? Three pans, 2 layers, what happened to third layer??
Hi, Mamie. If you read the note under the recipe, I tell what happened to the third layer.
If AP flour is used instead of cake flour should I use same amount IE 3 cups?
I’d recommend using cake flour if at all possible, but if you do substitute then use 2 tablespoons less flour for every cup in the recipe. So, for 3 cups of cake flour, you’d use 2 & 1/2 cups plus 2 tablespoons of all-purpose flour. If you like, you can replace those 6 tablespoons of flour with an equal amount of cornstarch to try to get the same effect as using cake flour.
Pingback: 10 Things I've Learned in 10 Years of Blogging - Bake or Break
This cake is GOOD!! It is worth every step.
My cake flour (Swans Down) does not contain a leavening agent. Do I need to add any baking powder or is the baking soda all I need?
You won’t need to add any more leavening.
Pingback: Butter Pecan Cheesecake - Bake or Break
I’ve been baking for years but this is the worse cake I’ve baked. I baked this for Thanksgiving 2016, never again. The frosting is delicious.
I made this cake for my dad’s birthday. It was very easy to make and turned out beautiful!!! Such a delicious cake!!! Thank you.
I baked the cake today and the frosting is delicious; the cake itself is ok. I was expecting a light and fluffy cake; similar to what you get from a bakery. This cake was moist but very dense. It took longer than 20-22 minutes to make; more like 30 minutes. Overall, the cake is good.
If I want to make a two layer cake like you, can I still use 9inch pans.
Yes, but you’ll need to scale the cake recipe by a third to accommodate just making two layers. Or you could make the excess into cupcakes if you like.
Thank you.
My husbands favorite ice cream is Butter Pecan, however I think after making this cake he’s had a change of heart! I made this cake on Sunday evening and I had to pat myself on the back. This is by far the BEST Butter Pecan Cake recipe I’ve ever tried! Thank you so much for sharing your recipe with us!
I’m glad you enjoyed it, Brandy!
This cake looks amazing but I’m confused by one thing- the recipe calls for 3 – 9″ pans but the photo of the cake looks like only 2 layers – wondering if this is a 2 or 3 layer cake?
Hi, Lauren. As I explained above, it is a 3-layer cake. My 3rd layer just didn’t turn out well when I was baking it to photograph.
I only have salted pecans. Can I use them in the frosting?
Hi, Lynn. It shouldn’t affect the consistency of the frosting, just the flavor.
Could I substitute the pecans for walnuts?
Sure!
Hello, I am not big on pecans. Could I use almonds or walnuts?
I think either would work.
I just made this for my dads birthday and it turned out amazing! He was blown away and said “you could make a lot of money selling this.” Lol! I have a gluten sensitivity so I used 1 to 1 Bobs gluten free baking flour in place of the cake flour and it worked perfectly. I did have to bake it about 8min longer but GF baking times can vary. Thank you so much for the recipe and making me look like a pro!
That’s so great to hear, Jamie! I appreciate your supplying info about how GF flour works in this recipe. And happy belated birthday to your dad.
Ma’am… Let me just say–it don’t make no sense–at ALL… for an icing to taste that dang good!
That stuff is just tasty, creamy…buttery…crunchy… GOODNESS on a cake. You should be arrested for peddlin’ such tastiness.
Travesty.
Thank you for your enthusiastic comment! 🙂 I’m so glad you liked it!