Cinnamon sugar cookie bars are sweet, super soft, and filled with plenty of cozy cinnamon flavor. These thick sugar cookies are great for feeding a crowd!
Soft Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Bars
I have a bit of an addiction to baking bars. To me, they’re the best of all baking worlds. Seriously, I could dedicate this entire blog to bar recipes. If I were to do that, I might start to bore some of you, so I soldier on with a little more variety. Today, though, we have bars!
I happened upon this recipe purely by accident over at Gilt Taste. The folks at Momofuku Milk Bar were featured in a series of articles about their favorite family cookie recipes. As soon as I saw this recipe for a bar that resembles a cinnamon sugar cookie, I was sold.
I very rarely make sugar cookies. I love their brilliant simplicity, but I ultimately skip over them in favor of something else. These bars offered just enough variation and interest to get me hooked.
These were simple to make and received a slew of compliments. They are very buttery and soft and just plain delicious. The original recipe indicates that these should be made into bite-size bars, yielding 150 bars. I cut mine a little larger and liked them that way. I still had plenty to share. If you’re baking for a crowd, which is not uncommon this time of year, bite-size will definitely give you enough bars to feed a lot of people.
More Sugar Cookie Recipes
There are so many ways to make addictive, easy sugar cookies! Check out some more recipes below.
- Drop Sugar Cookies
- Soft Christmas Sprinkle Sugar Cookies
- Sugar and Spice Cookies
- Brown Butter Sugar Cookies
Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Squares
Cinnamon sugar cookie bars are sweet, soft, and flavored with plenty of cinnamon. These thick sugar cookies are great for feeding a crowd!
Ingredients
- 1/2 cup (113g) unsalted butter, at room temperature
- 2 cups (400g) granulated sugar
- 1/2 cup (118ml) canola oil
- 2 large eggs
- 1/2 cup (118ml) milk
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 3 cups (360g) all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon salt
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- cinnamon sugar*
Instructions
- Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease an 11″x 15″ baking pan.
- Using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat the butter, sugar, oil, eggs, and milk. Mix in the vanilla.
- Reduce mixer speed to low. Add the flour, salt, and baking soda, and mix well.
- Pour the batter into the prepared pan. Spread evenly with an off-set spatula or knife. Sprinkle with cinnamon sugar.
- Bake 20 minutes, or until the edges are light brown. Allow to rest for 10 minutes. Then, cut into squares.
Notes
- *To make cinnamon sugar, mix 1/2 tablespoon ground cinnamon for every 1/4 cup granulated sugar.
- Yield: Makes about 60 bars.
- Recipe slightly adapted from Momofuku Milk Bar via Gilt Taste.
Recommended Products
Bake or Break is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
73 Comments on “Cinnamon Sugar Cookie Squares”
nice. this is a better was to have sugar cookies. way better!
These sound delightful!
Ohhh, these look fantastic!!
Aside from Momofuku’s compost cookie recipe, which is my favorite thing to bake, I prefer bars simply because they’re so much quicker and more satisfying.
Thanks for this recipe! And off to investigate the others!
These look great…..I’m a big fan of bar cookies too.
Any thoughts on changing the size of the pan? I have only a 9 x 13 pan. If that wouldn’t work, is the suggested pan a “jelly roll pan”?
Thanks for any thoughts…..you have a great site!
Marianne, if you don’t have an 11″x 17″ pan (which is a normal half sheet pan), then I would suggest making these in two 9″x 9″ pans. Or, half the recipe and use one 9″x 9″ pan. The bars will be a bit thicker, so you may need to bake them a little longer.
Can I use a different oil instead of Canola? Coconut oil?
Hi, Debbie. Coconut oil should be fine.
Thanks Jennifer!
They look too good to pass up because of a pan.
Wishing you all the best in 2012!
I love bars, too! These sugar cookie bars sound delicious, and I love the crispy sugar on top! Definitely going to make these!!
This is basically a brioche dough with a little more butter replacing the milk.
These are yummy! I made them for my preschooler’s Christmas pageant, and they went over really well. And I had plenty left over to keep at home, so my kids were able to stop complaining that I was giving them all away. Thank you!
Those look delicious…like bar snickerdoodles. I love the cinnamon and sugar on top. Going in the file of recipes to try!
Love the pictures, recipes and enthusiasm of your site! Thanks for the tips, recommendations and ideas! I’ll be a loyal follower!
so late to the party with these, but glad I arrived….they are DELICIOUS! So simple to pull together and they get better each day.
Definitely a keeper…love your blog!
I made these a few days ago, and they are great! They make a nice accompaniment to one’s morning coffee, I’ve found (I’ve been telling myself they’re like a little coffee cake, which seems slightly more acceptable than eating cookies for breakfast!). I’m looking forward to trying more of your recipes. Thank you!
I know this is an old entry but just gotta say I made these a couple days ago and now I am having to make them again. My boys DEVOURED them. I thought they were great and also will be making them for some upcoming bake sales. Thanks so much!
I wanted to know if anyone has made these in a 9 x 13 pyrex dish and if that would come out ok? If so how much cinnamon sugar did you use? Thanks.
Hi, Kathy. They’ll be a good bit thicker if you make them in a 9″x 13″ pan. If you don’t want to use an 11″x 15″ pan, then I’d recommend using a 9″-square pan and halving the recipe.
Has anyone stored these? Just wondering if I could make in advanced.
They should keep for a few days in an airtight container. Longer than that, and you might consider freezing them.
I dotted with butter before baking to make it even more decadent! Yum! I also cut the recipe in half, used and 8×8 and vanilla bean
Hi Jennifer,
Can you tell me how much cinnamon sugar you put on top? I want a nice layer like you showed in your photos. The topping looks amazing.
Thanks!
Ch, I didn’t measure it. You’ll just want to cover the top thoroughly and evenly in a thin layer.
I am glad you asked this question even though we didn’t get a good answer. I am a very precise baker and would have preferred a better idea 1/4 cup, 1/2 cup ?? of cinnamon sugar.
Jennifer I do love your recipes. Thank you.
Try starting with 1/4 cup. You can always add more if you prefer.
Oh these look amazing … can’t wait to make these .. do you think these would freeze well? Thanks for the wonderful recipe Jennifer 🙂 <3
I’ve never frozen these, so I can’t give you a definitive answer. But I think they’d be fine to freeze.
I made these tonight and I am freezing right now so maybe I can answer the previous question. Even though on a diet I did have to have a small piece and it was delicious. A sugar cookie in bar form. Nice and soft and the cinnamon sugar adds a nice effect. Also for minimal ingredients produces a lot of these even a good chunk sized. I will make these again!!
Sugar cookies are the best! I love the idea of making them in bar form!
Great twist on a classic.
Such a great dessert idea, they look so moist and delicious!
Love-Your-Site! Christmas is coming! October is the perfect month to try new big crowd recipes and these cinnamon sugar cookie squares are definitely on my dessert list for Christmas 2017. Thanks a bunch Jennifer for sharing the most important part of a meal with us…these are delights! I will most certainly come back for more, you have so many choices here, i’m in dessert heaven! Thanks again for the wonderful work you do here.
Hi, Sylvie! You’ve made my day! I hope you enjoy these bars and all of your holiday baking! 🙂
Hi Jennifer! Thinking about making these this evening! I’m curious though, can I substitute the butter for just another half cup of oil? Equaling the full oil amount to 1 cup?
Hi, Nichole. I don’t think you’ll get quite the same result, but you can certainly use that substitution. I believe you’ll need less oil, though. I think the substitution is usually 3/4 the amount of butter.
Thank you! I didn’t get to see your reply till just now. I did use the equal amount when I made them and it was a hit! I’m actually baking them again tonight but without any substitutions! Such an easy, hassle free recipe! My son and husband love them… sent some to my mother’s and they were equally loved!
I’m glad they’re a hit for you! And thanks for letting me know how that oil substitution worked.
I am interested in making these bars for an upcoming church event. I will need to make quite a few so I’ll need to bake in advance. My question is, do they freeze well? Thanks!
Hi, Michele. I’ve not tried freezing them, but I would think they would freeze well enough.
Hello. What do you think if I make two batches and bake them in a full sheet pan?
Best- Teresa
Hi, Teresa. I’ve not tried that, as I have a standard oven that won’t hold a full sheet pan. But I would guess it would work fine. The thickness of the bars wouldn’t really change, so I don’t think the baking time would be affected.
👍🏻😊
Their good but eggs seem to overpower the recipe
I baked these in a 9×13 glass pyrex before reading the comments :/ ) and they turned out really good. I did however cook them longer than the 20 minutes. I set the timer for an additional 10 minutes but checked on them after 5. These are definitely a keeper!
I’m so glad you liked them, Ceci! Glass pans don’t bake quite the same as a metal pan, so that could account for the timing difference.
Would buttermilk work with this recipe?
I haven’t tried it, but I would guess that it would work well enough. It will probably alter the taste and maybe the texture in some way.
Hi Jennifer! What kind of milk do you usually use when making this recipe? Thanks!
Hi, Allie. I generally use whatever I have in my fridge, which is usually 2%.
Hi could we use coconut sugar instead of normal sugar?
Hi, Isabella. I’ve not tried that with this recipe, so I couldn’t say with any certainty without testing it. If you usually make that substitution in baking with success, then it’s certainly worth a shot.
“Using an electric mixer on medium speed, beat the butter, sugar, oil, eggs, and milk.” So do you add all these ingredients to the mixer at the same time? and if so how long do you beat it for and how to tell it is ready for the flour mixture?
Yes, they’re mixed all at once. Mix them just until they’re thoroughly combined.
Hi, I would like to know what types of sugar substitutes can be used in this recipe? I’m on sugar free diet due to T2 diabetes, thanks.
Hi, Patricia. I don’t do much baking with sugar substitutes, so I can’t confidently recommend any. If you have one you like, then I’d suggest using the manufacturer’s guidelines for substitution.
Just made it. And it’s delicious!
Made these today since my granddaughter is staying for a week and is always hungry after school. Didn’t have an 11 x 15 pan so I made them in a jelly roll pan and cut the baking time by 5 minutes. They are a hit. I like the cinnamon sugar on top. It gives it a old time warmth with not a lot of work.
I’m glad to hear they were a hit, Evelyn!
Hi, thank you for your blog. I always find great recipes. With COVID my kids won’t be home for the holidays so I plan to ship cookies to them this year. Do you think that these would ship well? Thank you.
Thanks, Christy! These are pretty soft, so I would be sure to pack them really well for shipping so they don’t fall apart.
Hi! I can’t wait to try this! I’m slightly confused by the pan size though. Did you bake this on a standard rimmed cookie sheet? How deep is your pan?
Thank you!
Hi, Sarah. There’s a photo and link to the type of pan I use at the bottom of the recipe. It’s the general shape of a half sheet pan, so it’s about an inch deep. It’s smaller, though, with the width and length specified in the recipe. Hope you enjoy the cookie bars!
Hi. I don’t get it. I love Sugar Cookies. I love Snickerdoodles. These cinnamon sugar cookie bars are so oily! I have made these 3 times. I made 2 batches in two separate ovens at a friends home as I was baking for a big party and wanted to use both ovens. I mixed 2 separate batches. They were so greasy. About a week later, I made a batch at home, just to see if her oven may have been off temp. Different oven and cooked 5 extra minutes total 25 min. Still oily which distracted from the sweet cinnamon topping. I wanted to love these but I know I won’t
make again. I The reviews were so good, which is why I tried at home. Also, mine never looked like the picture which looks light fluffy yellow, almost cake-like.
I’m sorry you had troubles, Emily! Is it possible something is off with your ingredients? Either with the measurements, a substitution or even a sub-par ingredient?
Tasty bars! Made them yesterday. I was kind of confused about the pan size, since 11×15 isn’t a size I’m familiar with. I went with my standard 10×15 jelly-roll pan, as it was closer to the specified pan size than my standard half-sheet pan, at 13×18. Unfortunately, the batter overflowed the pan onto the oven floor, and I had to cut the edges off since they were curled up over the pan on all four sides. Next time, I’ll go with the half-sheet pan and shorten the timing a bit. Thanks for the recipe!
I’m glad you liked the bars, Anne! You can definitely use a larger pan if you don’t have an 11×15. Just keep in mind that the bars may bake faster because they’re thinner.
Can these be baked in a 16 x 12 pan? I don’t have the 11 X 15 and wanted to make these for a function this weekend,
Hi, Kristy! They’ll be thinner in that size pan, so you’d need to reduce the baking time. I’ve not tried these in that size pan, so I can’t say for sure how to make that adjustment.
I baked it for about 17 and think I could have done the full 20. A couple of middle pieces were really underbaked. It is very good, my husband and I both tried a piece and I am sure it will be a hit this weekend!!
Thanks for letting me know how it turned out, Kristy! I hope everyone enjoyed them!
Does almond milk work okay or do you need whole milk?
Hi, Rachel! I haven’t tried using almond milk here, but I think you’d get a comparable result. Let me know how it works if you try it. Enjoy!