Bake or Break
New to BAKE or BREAK? Start Here!

Best Thanksgiving Desserts

Enjoy some of BoB’s best Thanksgiving desserts, from cakes to cheesecakes to cobblers and a whole lot in between!

Thanksgiving Desserts That Aren't Pie bakeorbreak.com

The Best Thanksgiving Dessert Recipes

While I’m still of the mindset that Thanksgiving is primarily about the pies, I absolutely feel there’s room for some other desserts as well. It’s good to have a little variety, right?

Here are some of my favorite desserts to make for Thanksgiving. I’ve got cakes, cobblers, cheesecakes, and more. I’ve even got more casual options like cookies and brownies. There are some from way back in the archives and some much more recent favorites, too.

And be sure to follow along with my baking adventures for a few more dessert ideas coming your way!

I hope these recipe suggestions help you plan your best Thanksgiving yet! Do let me know what’s on your holiday dessert menu. And remember to tag me on Instagram if you make a recipe from BoB!

Enjoy! And happy Thanksgiving! (And if you still want pie, click here!)

How Much Dessert Should I Make for Thanksgiving?

There’s no hard and fast rule because every group of guests is different. Some will want to just have a small serving after the big meal, while others may want to sample a bit of everything! If you have the same or mostly the same crowd year after year, then you probably have a pretty clear idea of how much you’ll need.

At a minimum, count on one serving per person. I usually err on the side of abundance and have at least two servings per person. If it’s not all eaten right away, that just means delicious leftovers!

Best Thanksgiving Desserts {That Aren't Pie!}

These recipes offer a departure from the traditional pies of Thanksgiving in favor of cakes, cheesecakes, and more. With a variety of flavors, there's sure to be something here for everyone!

Cakes

A beautiful, delicious cake is a wonderful ending to your Thanksgiving meal! These cakes feature seasonal flavors along with some year-round favorites. There's a lot of territory to cover here, so we'll start with layer cakes and then move on to Bundt cakes, one-layer cakes, and finally mini cakes.

Cobblers, Crisps, and Crumbles

A warm, gooey fruit dessert hits the spot after all that turkey and trimmings. And they're a good excuse to enjoy a little ice cream, too.

Cheesecakes

Cheesecakes are one of my go-to desserts for a special occasion. They generally take some time to make, but they're usually really easy to mix and assemble. For something a little different, I've included some cheesecake bars and no-bake varieties as well.

Casual Desserts

Thanksgiving dessert doesn't have to be a grand affair. How about serving a variety of cookies, brownies, and other smaller fare? Or a simple coffee cake for entertaining visitors in a more relaxed setting?

Everything Else

These desserts offer some nontraditional options for your holiday meal. There's a lot to be found a little off the beaten dessert path!

Share this:

    9 Comments on “Best Thanksgiving Desserts”

  1. Excellent, I like having a combination of the pies, cobblers, and bars. This way everyone has what they like. They are also great for leftovers.

  2. Thanks for all the wonderful ideas! Will try and pass on many soon.

  3. OMG why did I choose today to visit? There isn’t ONE of these desserts that’s not to die for good looking. The pecan cake is screaming, “Make me first!!” but it’s so hard to decide.

  4. I really really really want a slice of each.

  5. Great round-up! I want all of them 🙂

  6. Thanks so much for these; caramel is a food group.

  7. Even though I love the pies, I ‘m usually looking for something chocolate too. So the flourless chocolate cake has definitely gotten my attention!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.